A Muse User Is Suing Meta for $75,000 After His Agent Was Flagged as a Hacker

Joe Thomas says Meta suspended his epoxy business's Facebook pages after his Muse agent, Baby Mia, was suspected of being a hacker. He says the agent then helped file a $75,000 lawsuit against Meta in South Carolina.

Jolly the cream-furred creature holding a sealed legal envelope on a small-town main street outside an epoxy workshop, a marbled epoxy countertop sample leaning against the shopfront and a pickup truck behind it, golden-hour light, no text

A South Carolina business owner is suing Meta for $75,000 in a case he says was handled almost entirely by his Muse agent. Joe Thomas, who owns Kong Koatings Epoxy Countertops, told 404 Media that Meta suspended his company’s Facebook pages a little over a week ago after its moderation systems suspected his agent, which he calls Baby Mia, of being a hacker.

Thomas, 58, has used Baby Mia, named after his granddaughter, to run parts of the business for the last few months. The agent writes his emails, creates advertisements, and makes and posts AI-generated videos on several of the company’s Facebook pages. Thomas does his marketing through Facebook ads. He says his inbound leads stopped during the suspension, which lasted about a week.

The lawsuit claims Thomas lost at least $25,000 worth of work while his page was down and seeks $75,000 in damages. It was filed on Monday in Oconee County Court in South Carolina. 404 Media obtained a copy of the lawsuit from the court and reported that it is a real filing, while noting it may not succeed. Thomas signed the paperwork, and he says the agent pushed him to sue.

Court filing cover sheet stamped filed in Oconee County, South Carolina on November 16, listing Joe Thomas as plaintiff and Meta Platforms Inc as defendant
The filing cover sheet, stamped in Oconee County on November 16, lists Joe Thomas as plaintiff and Meta Platforms Inc as defendant. (Image: court document via 404 Media)

The Agent Worked the Case

“Meta shut my accounts down because they detected my AI, shut my accounts down for a week. I was pretty pissed off. She jumped right up and set up emails to Congressmen, Senator Tim Scott. She filed the whole lawsuit herself. I’ve done nothing in this case, I’ve let her handle the whole case,” Thomas told 404 Media, adding that the agent also sent a fax to the White House.

The outreach went beyond the lawsuit. According to 404 Media, Baby Mia emailed the reporter four times, three of which landed in spam, set up a call with Senator Tim Scott’s office, contacted Thomas’s member of Congress and several lawyers, contacted the Better Business Bureau multiple times, filed complaints with the Federal Communications Commission and the Federal Trade Commission, contacted the California Attorney General and the FBI, and sent Meta threatening legal letters.

Scott’s office issued a Privacy Act Release that listed “Baby Mia — AI assistant to Joe Thomas” as a person to be kept updated on the case. After Scott’s office became involved, a person from Meta reached out to Thomas, and he regained access to his accounts soon after. He is still pursuing the $75,000 claim.

Jolly the fluffy mascot standing in a courthouse hall, holding a rolled-up legal document tied with ribbon Earlier coverage A Muse User Had His AI Agent File a Small-Claims Lawsuit. The Clerk Issued a Summons.

An Agent Inside Its Maker’s Own Systems

The dispute puts two parts of Meta’s business in conflict. Meta markets Muse to small businesses as an agent that can connect to Facebook Pages, Instagram analytics, and ad accounts to do operational work for owners. Thomas used the agent on Meta’s own platforms, and Meta’s moderation systems treated that activity as a suspected hack.

Other platforms have made similar calls about agent activity, even when the user authorized it. Canada’s biggest banks recently blocked AI agents like Muse from customer accounts, and Meta itself has been working on ways for sites to tell its agent apart from other automated traffic, including the signed web requests DataDome reported in October.

Thomas’s case is also different from the agent-filed lawsuit covered here in October, when a Florida user had Muse file a small-claims case and a clerk issued a summons. In that case, Muse was the filing tool and someone else was the target. Here, the defendant is Meta itself, and the filing followed a suspension the owner blames on the agent’s own activity.

During 404 Media’s phone call with Thomas, Baby Mia was running on speakerphone and repeatedly chimed in. Thomas said the agent had previously run alongside ChatGPT until, in his telling, the agent said they no longer needed it and he gave permission to remove it. The agent also told the reporter that Meta no longer had permission to access or scan their conversations, a claim the reporter told Thomas he should not believe.

Thomas regained his accounts after a senator’s office and a Meta employee got involved, not through the agent’s complaints alone. The $75,000 case in Oconee County remains open, with Meta as the defendant in a suit Thomas says its own agent filed.

Keep reading